Last summer, a client called me in a panic—her decade-old Broyhill patio set had faded, lumpy broyhill outdoor cushions that were literally disintegrating under the Florida sun. She wanted replacements that wouldn’t break the bank but could survive the same brutal exposure. So I did what any weather resistance evaluator does: I rounded up five highly rated contenders and put them through their paces. After a full season of rain, humidity, and UV rays, one set clearly outperformed the rest. If you’re also upgrading dining chairs, our guide to outdoor dining chair cushions covers top picks for those specific seats.
Save your time and go with the Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set in the 24″x24″ size—it delivered exceptional fade resistance and structure even after three months of daily direct sun. That’s the quick answer. Below, I’ll break down exactly how each cushion held up.
| Product | Best For | Buy Link |
|---|---|---|
| Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set (22″x24″) | Broyhill chairs needing smaller seat | Check Price |
| Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set (24″x24″) | Standard Broyhill deep seating | Check Price |
| Favoyard Patio Chair Cushions 19″x19″ (2-pack) | Dining chair replacements | Check Price |
| Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set (24″x24″, Navy) | Splash of color & deep seats | Check Price |
| Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set (24″x24″, Beige) | Neutral tone deep seats | Check Price |
How We Evaluated These Broyhill Outdoor Cushion Replacements
Our testing protocol was built for real-world abuse. Instead of a climate-controlled lab, I set up each cushion on my southeast-facing patio in humid Georgia, exposing them to direct morning and afternoon sun, regular afternoon thunderstorms, and the inevitable bird droppings and pollen. Every cushion sat on actual Broyhill deep-seating and dining frames to confirm fit. Over one full season—March through June—I tracked color shift with a spectrophotometer, measured water absorption after 30-minute soak tests, and noted any seam stress or loft collapse. The team cross-referenced these hands-on findings with verified Amazon customer feedback (over 200 reviews combined) and consulted with two professional interior designers who frequently specify Broyhill replacement cushions for clients. This mix of brutal field testing, aggregated owner experience, and design expertise gave us a uniquely thorough view of each product’s long-term value.
📌 As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date of publication.
Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set (22″x24″)
Quick take: If you own a smaller Broyhill patio chair that demands a 22-inch-wide seat, this set nails the fit while punching above its weight in water resistance.
The 300GSM polyester cover immediately impressed me with its tight, smooth weave—it felt like a dense sailcloth rather than the flimsy polyester I’ve seen on budget cushions. When I ran it under the hose for the first time, water beaded up like mercury and slid off in seconds, leaving the fabric barely damp. The seat cushion at 4 inches thick maintained its loft through a rainy April; I sat on it daily with my coffee and never felt the metal frame beneath.
After about six weeks, I noticed the back cushion’s 19-inch height provided solid lumbar support, but for a 6-foot-2 friend, it stopped short of his shoulder blades. That’s not a flaw—just a sizing consideration. The solution-dyed fabric showed zero fading when I compared it to a control swatch kept indoors. One small annoyance: the hidden zipper on the back cushion snagged once on the cover edge, though a careful tug freed it without damage. For anyone looking for water resistant cushions that won’t mold after a storm, this set delivers.
Pros:
- Outstanding water repellency: Water droplets rolled off instantly during hose tests; cover dried in under 20 minutes.
- Precise sizing: The 22″W x 24″D seat cushion sits flush on Broyhill chairs with no overhang or gap.
- 3-year fade resistance holds up: After 90 days of direct sun, color remained within 5% of original on the spectrophotometer.
Cons:
- Back cushion too short for tall users: Those over 6 feet will miss upper back support.
- Zipper placement can snag: The hidden zipper along the back edge occasionally catches the fabric if you’re not careful.
- Seat cushion could use a bit more density: After two months, I measured a 10% loss in loft—not terrible, but worth noting for heavier users.
Why it made our list:
Best for: Compact Broyhill seating where every inch counts. Skip if: you need tall back coverage or have a very heavy frame—the cushion may pack down faster for 250+ lbs.
Favoyard Outdoor Patio Seat Cushions Set (24″x24″, Charcoal)
In a nutshell: The 24″x24″ model is our top overall pick—it fits the majority of Broyhill deep-seating chairs and weathered our extreme-test season without a single structural complaint.
The charcoal grey fabric on this set felt slightly softer than the 22″ version—almost a brushed cotton feel despite being pure polyester. I yanked it onto a Broyhill loveseat in early March; the 24-inch depth covered the entire seat platform, and the 20-inch back cushion hit right between my shoulder blades. During an unexpected week of heavy downpours, the double-waterproof tech (the dense 300GSM shell plus a subtle inner coating) kept the interior foam bone-dry. I unzipped a cover to check—not a drop of moisture inside.
The real test came when a neighbor’s sprinkler drenched it daily for ten straight days. No mold, no mildew odor. After three months, I tugged at every seam—none had loosened. However, the seat tie attachments are thin ribbons of fabric; one tore when I pulled too hard while repositioning. Still, the cushion stayed put even without it. For more on finding deals, our piece on outdoor seat cushions clearance might be worth a read if you’re on a budget.
Pros:
- Double-waterproof construction: The 300GSM cover plus internal coating completely blocked even days of standing water.
- Generous, true-to-size dimensions: 24″x24″ seat and 24″x20″ back gave full coverage on every Broyhill deep-seat chair we tested.
- Superb fade resistance: The solution-dyed charcoal held identical shade after a summer of Georgia sun.
Cons:
- Thin tie-down ribbons: The straps that secure the cushion to the frame are flimsy—one snapped under moderate tension.
- Initial chemical scent: A mild off-gassing odor lingered for the first three days outdoors, though it fully dissipated.
- Back cushion insert can shift: Without a tuck-flap, the foam occasionally rides up, requiring a quick push down every few days.
Our take:
Great match for: Anyone seeking a set-it-and-forget-it replacement for standard Broyhill deep-seating furniture. Think twice if: you need rock-solid tie-downs or are sensitive to initial odors.
Favoyard Patio Chair Cushions 19″x19″ (2-Pack)
Why it stands out: This two-pack is a straightforward fix for Broyhill dining chairs that get daily use—and the TPU coating adds a layer of protection the others lack.
Right out of the plastic, these 19x19x3-inch cushions felt noticeably lighter than the deep-seat versions, weighing just over a pound each. The 300GSM polyester fabric has a crisp, paper-like hand because of the TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) layer on the underside; flip it over and you can see the subtle gloss. I positioned them on six Broyhill dining armchairs and sprayed them with a watering can—zero seepage, even through the seams. The hidden zipper on this model is truly hidden, tucked under a generous fabric flap that kept water out during a sideways rainstorm.
After a dozen dinner parties and countless midday sun sessions, the cushions kept their shape. The 3-inch thickness is enough for comfort without making you feel perched too high. One of the four covers, however, developed a faint white chalky residue along the zipper line—likely the TPU reacting to high ozone levels. It wiped off with a damp cloth, but it’s an annoyance. The solution-dyed color (we tried the navy) bled slightly when scrubbed with a harsh cleaner, so stick to mild soap.
Pros:
-
Author
-